Explore Advisory with Furqan, live · Mon 2 Nov, 6 PMSave my seat
uraan logo

Invest in the RIGHT cement company!

Published October 29, 2023

11:31

How to Analyze Cement Companies for Investment

If you're looking at the cement sector, you need to understand that it's fundamentally different from, say, the fertilizer sector. The way you evaluate a cement company is not the same as evaluating a consumer goods company. In this guide, I'll walk you through the key factors that drive cement businesses—capacity, market share, price discipline, and cycles—so you can make informed investment decisions.

The Cement Sector Is a Capacity Business

First, let's get one thing straight: cement is a capacity business. That means the company's ability to produce and sell is tied directly to its installed capacity. Unlike some industries where you can ramp up production quickly, cement requires massive capital investment in plants and equipment. So when you look at a cement company, you're essentially looking at how well it manages its capacity.

But it's not just about having capacity—it's about market share. Cement companies compete on capacity, but they also need to capture a share of the market. That's why I call it a "capacity market share business." Steel and auto companies are similar, but cement has its own quirks.

Price Discipline Matters

One of the most critical aspects of the cement sector is price discipline. In many industries, companies can differentiate on product quality or brand. In cement, the product is largely commoditized. So the only way to maintain margins is through disciplined pricing. If one company undercuts, the whole sector suffers. That's why you see cement companies often operating in cartel-like behavior—they need to keep prices stable to survive.

The Role of Cycles

Cement is also a cyclical business. When the economy is growing, infrastructure and construction demand rise, and cement companies do well. But when the economy slows down, demand drops, and capacity can become a burden. If a company has taken on too much debt to expand capacity, a downturn can be devastating. So you need to pay attention to where we are in the economic cycle.

How to Analyze a Cement Company

Now, let's get practical. When you're evaluating a cement company, you should look at its capacity growth over time and how that correlates with its operating profit. I've seen charts that show capacity in blue and operating profit in orange. The key insight is that capacity and profit move together—when capacity comes online, profits tend to follow, but only if the market can absorb the supply.

Look at Capacity Expansion Plans

Check the company's expansion plans. Are they adding new capacity? When will it come online? For example, if a company has capacity coming online in FY24-25, you need to assess whether demand will be there to absorb it. If the sector is already oversupplied, that new capacity could hurt margins.

Compare Capacity and Operating Profit

Plot the company's capacity against its operating profit over several years. You'll see that when capacity increases, operating profit often follows—but with a lag. If you see capacity growing without a corresponding rise in profit, that's a red flag. It might mean the company is struggling to sell its output or facing pricing pressure.

Watch Price Discipline

Keep an eye on the sector's pricing behavior. If companies are undercutting each other, margins will compress. Look for signs of price stability or even price increases. A company that can maintain or improve its prices while growing capacity is a strong candidate.

Consider the Cycle

Finally, think about where we are in the economic cycle. If the economy is booming, cement demand is high, and capacity additions are likely to be profitable. But if we're heading into a downturn, new capacity could become a liability. You want to invest in a company that has a strong balance sheet and can weather a downturn.

Putting It All Together

So, when you're looking at a cement company, don't just look at the stock price or the P/E ratio. Dig into the numbers. Check the capacity, the operating profit, the pricing environment, and the cycle. If you like the story, go ahead and check the numbers yourself. If they add up, you can consider buying. But if the numbers don't support the story, it's better to pass.

The cement sector is not for everyone. It requires patience and a willingness to understand the underlying business dynamics. But if you do your homework, you can find solid investment opportunities in this cyclical, capacity-driven industry.

5.9KViews
193Likes
27Comments
@rafiquesuleman7406
@rafiquesuleman74062y ago

The speaker emphasizes the importance of capacity growth and market share allocation in the cement industry, it doesn't address the consequential **capacity underutilization** issue, which can lead to higher unit production costs. Let’s break this down: 1. **Capacity Underutilization** The speaker's model relies on the idea that expanding capacity leads to profitability because of proportional market share. However, the **cement industry often suffers from overcapacity**, meaning that companies build capacity but cannot fully utilize it due to limited demand. This results in **idle capacity**, which increases the per-unit cost of production. If a company only operates at 50% of its capacity, the fixed costs are spread over fewer units, driving up the cost of each unit. 2. **Market Share Allocation Flaw** Allocating market share based on capacity sounds efficient in theory, but it can create **market inefficiencies**. When companies are restricted to selling according to their proportional capacity rather than adjusting to demand fluctuations, they may be **forced to maintain higher prices** to cover the cost of underutilized capacity. This artificial allocation discourages competition and efficiency, resulting in an industry-wide inefficiency. 3. **Impact on Consumers** The higher unit costs directly affect consumers. Since cement companies can't lower their costs due to underutilization, the **end prices remain higher**. This model ends up **protecting producers but hurting consumers**, who are paying more than they would in a more competitive, demand-driven pricing model. 4. **The Role of the Competition Commission** The **Competition Commission** should indeed intervene here. The current model of market share allocation based on capacity can be seen as anti-competitive. It **limits market forces** from optimizing production and pricing, and instead, locks companies into a high-cost structure. The commission needs to **ensure that market competition is healthy**, and companies are encouraged to produce based on **real market demand** rather than their installed capacity. By addressing these inefficiencies, they can help bring down costs and, ultimately, consumer prices. 5. **Long-Term Industry Sustainability** In the long run, this flawed model could be detrimental to the industry as well. **Continued overcapacity** can lead to financial strain on companies, especially when they take on debt to expand capacity without the matching demand growth. This could result in a downward spiral where companies need to raise prices or cut costs to stay afloat, hurting both consumers and the industry’s sustainability. **Conclusion** The analysis presented in the video does overlook the consequences of capacity underutilization and its impact on production costs. The model of allocating market share based on capacity, while beneficial for companies in the short term, **increases unit costs**, reduces competitiveness, and ultimately makes consumers suffer. A more demand-responsive and competitive approach is needed to ensure that both the industry and its consumers benefit in the long run.

2
@InvestKaar
@InvestKaar3y ago

Join the community: https://community.investkaar.com/

1
@irfansahi4207
@irfansahi42074mo ago

You are actually talking about PEG❤

1
@naveedshakoor3676
@naveedshakoor36763y ago

Great Job bro

1
@zameerhussain9707
@zameerhussain97073y ago

Excellent sir!

1
Do you need some help?!